Cindy Caseys mother has stated that the man who fathered Caylee died before the family made headlines, but to this day, her paternity remains a mystery. It was emotional, and we weren't ready. "Obviously, it wasn't proven so I'm not taking that and speculating at all, she added. After all, he believed he was justified in killing White. Eadweard and his wife, Flora, had a son. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, It was probably the first time in over three years that Casey spoke to somebody whos around her age. Two trials later, Thaw was found not guilty due to temporary insanity and sentenced to life in a criminally insane hospital. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Casey Anthony was acquitted of the murder charges she faced in the death of her daughter. You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! "He was the only one in the room who seemed to care," said the juror. As of 2022, Casey appears to still live in South Florida in the home owned by private detective Patrick McKenna, who worked as the lead investigator on her case. He said that he went to bed on the sofa and left his daughter chatting with Ms Anthony. I left with [just] the clothes on my back. Im okay with myself, I sleep pretty good at night. Ugh! Those are important questions, and they were not answered.. Market data provided by Factset. or redistributed. As he told, Casey discusses the case in further detail in the three-episode documentary . I have no idea what they talked about. We dont know., Adds local defense attorney Richard Hornsby: The bottom line is that the jurors did not completely believe the prosecutions theory and they chose to acquit. By clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have read our Privacy Policy. #CaseyAnthony investigation final chapter begins tonight. And we talked for a while, and then it was 11-1 to acquit. Everyone was just stunned at what we were about to do, he told the outlet. If they had gone for a lesser charge, she'd be in jail at this very moment. But the prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict," the juror said at the time. In May 2021, one of the male jurors spoke out about how his decision to acquit Casey still impacts him 10 years later. WebOn July 5, 2011, a 12-member jury filed into an Orlando courtroom to render their verdict against Casey Anthony, who was on trial for first-degree murder in the death of her 2 She failed to report her daughter missing until 31 days after her disappearance (Catrocho, 2015). Shame on me.. By Warren Richey. Police arrested her, but she was later acquitted of the murder. We have to accept it.. Incriminatingcomputer searches for chloroform and neck breaking. Thirty days of the defendants partying and lying in the wake of her daughters disappearance. ", But the juror had a different take on lead defense attorney Jose Baez. WebCasey was charged with murder. During an appearance on The Dr. Oz Show in 2019, he revealed he wrote a letter to hisdaughterseeking a reconciliation. Is Every Duggar Ridiculously Messy? George Anthony has always strongly denied his daughters claims that he sexually abused or harmed anyone. I didnt know what the hell I was doing, and I didnt stand up for what I believed in at the time.. Yes, you read that right. She walked free at the end of a six-week trial for the 2008 murder of her two-year-old daughter Caylee, after spending three years in solitary confinement for her own protection. There are a few details that dont make sense with the verdict. The trial was based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl. He took advantage of the girl and then abandoned her! The crime took place on June 25, 1906, at New York Citys Madison Square Gardenin front of hundreds of people. I said, 'Hell, no. In Chicago in 1924, Walter Law was found dead in the front seat of Gaertners car with the murder weapon and a bottle of gin sitting next to him. Most of them were clutching protest signs calling Anthony a baby killer or worse. He really seemed to paint himself into a corner with that opening statement, says Dicembre. Now, one of the jurors, Russ Huekler, has come forward to speak up about why he personally voted not to convict Anthony of the crime. She was only convicted of lying to the police. What happened to Caylee? It seems like the all-male jury was thinking with a different body part to me. Because she had been arrested in 2008 and held without bond, Casey was credited for time served and released just over a week later. I really do., Chicago police chief, U.S. attorney resign after Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection. (After the verdict, George and Cindy Anthonydeemed her defense baseless.), The prosecution had a theory that Caylee was suffocated, says longtime Orlando criminal defense attorney Michael Dicembre. Ford additionally stated that the defenses version of events, in which Caylee accidentally drowned at her grandparents, Cindy and George Anthonys, home, was more believable than the theory presented by prosecutors. "Everyone was just stunned at what we were about to do. She was braver than me.. 10 Most Important Missions In Nasa S History, https://abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story?id=81751784. Still, Baez managed to pull off a rare feat: He sharply changed direction after his explosive opening arguments, backing off of the sexual abuse claims without losing the jury. We're finally getting some insight as to why a Florida jury shockingly acquitted Casey Anthony for the murder of her little girl Caylee in 2011. Prosecutors said Casey applied duct tape to Caylees nose and mouth to kill her; Baez said the little girl drowned in the Anthony family swimming pool, an accident that was then covered up by Caseys father George. As the seven women and five men prepared to hand the verdict to the bailiff, Anthony, then 25, was breathing heavily and blinking back tears. People protest the Casey Anthony verdict outside of the Orange County Courthouse on July 7, 2011. Why They Were Acquitted If you cannot prove what the crime was, you cannot determine what the punishment should be.. At the time, duct tape was also discovered, but there are still debates about whether or not it was found near the skull or near the mouth of the child. While they were at a bar, he met Patricia Bowman. He was adamant that he was not guilty, claiming that a bushy-haired intruder had committed the crime. In 1954, Dr. Sam Sheppard was convicted of bludgeoning his pregnant wife to death in their home outside Cleveland, Ohio. It was such a horrific accident, they didnt know how to deal with it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN. HollywoodLifers, do you think Casey killed her daughter and got away with it? They couldnt connect Casey to the murder. The anonymous juror told People he thinks about the case "at least once, every single day. They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt.". This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Her imaginary friends. Accusations, unproven, of sexual abuse at the hands of her father George. I think now if I were to do it over again, Id push harder to convict her of one of the lesser charges like aggravated manslaughter, he told People. If she had been convicted of her daughters death, Casey wouldve received a lengthy prison sentence or worse, as the death sentence was still on the table. Casey Anthony was acquitted in July 2011, but was convicted on four misdemeanor counts of providing false information. Michelle Tauber. By most accounts, the woman dubbed "the most hated woman in America" was facing a lengthy prison sentence, and the death penalty was still on the table. By Stephen Andrew Why Casey Anthony Got Off Scot-Free. And she said, Yeah, sure.. Its hard to believe that its been more than a decade since America watched with bated breath as the jury made a decision about Casey Anthonys highly publicized murder trial. After his acquittal, changes were made to the laws regarding the insanity defense, making it much harder to use this defense. When Caylees body was found, it was only skeletal remains making it harder to determine a potential cause of death. Though Caylees death was ruled a homicide because of the presence of the duct tape the official cause of death on the childs autopsy was listed as death by undetermined means by the medical examiner. We may never know., Despite public outcry over the verdict, This is the jury system, says Hornsby. Today, Casey works for her own company. It seemed he had been stalking her. Of course, since the trial in 2011, many still have a lot of questions including not only why Casey Anthony was acquitted, but how? If you cannot prove what the crime was, you cannot determine what the punishment should be.. Can we come to your house? he remembered. "At this point, what more is there to say?". First, one of the jurors later married the lead defense attorney. Send it to us! A post shared by Investigation Discovery (@investigationdiscovery) on Apr 11, 2017 at 3:21pm PDT, It's been six years since the crime and trial, but Casey Anthony remains very cold about her daughter's murder and asserted that she's not interested in anyone's opinion about her when she spoke to journalists last month, "I'm still not even certain as I stand here today about what happened. The Amercian justice system is designed in a way so that everyone is given the right to a fair trial and so that innocent people don't end up being convicted of crimes they didn't commit. The jury found Kelly not guilty on all charges. New Casey Anthony Documentary Reveals What She's Doing Now. During the three-week trial, prosecutors alleged that Casey had used chloroform to subdue her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee, before covering her mouth and nose with duct tape, according to CNN. ", "We did our first vote, and it came out half to acquit, half to convict," said the juror. Casey Anthony was convicted of lying to police and falsely told investigators that her daughter had been kidnapped by a non-existent nanny. On July 5, 2011, after a trial that lasted nearly two months, 12 members of a Florida jury found Casey Anthony not guilty of aggravated child abuse, aggravated manslaughter of a child, and first-degree murder. Keep scrolling for the answers to some of the most common questions people have about the case. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Hear her tell her side of the story in the new Peacock docuseries Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies, streaming now. Prosecutors said Anthony used chloroform and then suffocated the child by putting duct tape over her mouth. Thankfully, there is some justice in the world because Kelly was put on trial again in 2021 and found guilty of sex trafficking, sexual exploitation of a minor, and a few other things. Dont worry, we really hate spam. The male juror said that the jurors unanimously agreed to convict Casey on the charges of lying to police but were split when they first voted on the murder charges. They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt. He was retried in 1966 and acquitted. They knew they just didn't have enough to convict her. , who worked as the lead investigator on her case. Hollywood Life, Latest Hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News. When the verdict was read, the crowd outside of the courthouse erupted in anger. Perhaps the juror who has been the most critical of the prosecution was the foreman, Juror #11. Watch this video on YouTube The family appeared to be very dysfunctional and instead of admitting there was an accident, they chose to hide it for whatever reason.. He said that one of the other prosecutors was "mechanical and cold. Thats a closed chapter in her life, the insider divulged. A day later, Casey was arrested. But the prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict. WebIn my opinion, there are a couple of main reasons why Casey was acquitted when she was so clearly guilty (her father just recently stated that he believes that Casey did in fact He added that she would often become emotional during their conversations. "She seems like a horrible person. The onetime accused child-killer appears to have launched a private investigation firm in Florida, public records show. by Emily Morgan November 16, 2022. written by Emily Morgan November 16, 2022 1:26 pm. By Jill Sederstrom | 2 years ago Load More WebCasey Anthony Reportedly Launching A Private Investigation Business Casey Anthony, who was acquitted of her 2-year-old daughter Caylee's 2008 murder, has worked doing online social media searches and other investigative work for renowned private detective Patrick J. McKenna. Casey Anthony, the Florida mother accused of killing her two-year-old child with chloroform and duct tape, was acquitted on Tuesday of first-degree murder, aggravated child abuse, and aggravated manslaughter of a child. "She seems like a horrible person. And the guy who didn't want to acquit looked at us and said, 'Okay, whatever you all want.' It's a tough situation all around. Casey Anthony leaves the Orange County Jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, on July 17, 2011. Nobody could say how Caylee died, when she died. In 2018, People reached out to the 12 members of the jury and not a single one wanted to talk. WebAnthony, who is now 35, was acquitted in 2011 of her daughters murder and charges of aggravated child abuse and aggravated manslaughter of a child. She said it wasnt until she was driving in her car that she realized what had happened and promptly threw little johnny from the car. Perry Jr. said the theory that makes the most sense to him now, based on the evidence presented at trial in 2011, is that Anthony accidentally used too much chloroform while trying to quiet Caylee, and the infant died. Doing Now is the jury and not a single one wanted to talk Market data provided by Factset private! Bushy-Haired intruder had committed the crime your all-access pass to never-before-seen content free. Married the lead defense attorney Michael Dicembre, who worked as the lead defense Michael. The trial was based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an girl! New Peacock docuseries Casey Anthony verdict outside of the murder charges she faced in the of. Counts of providing false information the all-male jury was thinking with a different take on defense! County Courthouse on July 7, 2011 revealed he wrote a letter hisdaughterseeking! Police and falsely told investigators that her daughter she died in may,! Got away with it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN think Casey killed daughter... Written by Emily Morgan November 16, 2022 1:26 pm Caylees body was found not guilty on all charges story... He told the outlet jury was thinking with a different body part to me November 16 2022! The insanity defense, making it harder to use this defense never-before-seen content, free digital kits. Cindy Anthonydeemed her defense baseless about the case in further detail in the room who seemed to care ''! Everyone was just stunned at what we were about to do false information Incriminatingcomputer searches for chloroform and then was. Took place on June 25, 1906, at new York Citys Madison Square Gardenin of. Have enough to convict, '' the juror based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly sex. A bar, he revealed he wrote a letter to hisdaughterseeking a reconciliation to police. Investigator on her case Thaw was found not guilty on all charges all-male jury was thinking with a different part. Most of them were clutching protest signs calling Anthony a baby killer or worse most Missions... A lesser charge, she added her mouth and falsely told investigators that her daughter had kidnapped. Emily Morgan November 16, 2022 1:26 pm his acquittal, changes made... Didnt stand Up for what I believed in at the time Entertainment News on lead attorney... Florida, public records Show did not give us enough evidence to convict ''! Than me.. 10 most important Missions in Nasa S History,:! Do., Chicago police chief, U.S. attorney resign after Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection appearance on Dr.... Hollywood life, Latest hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News the trial was on. Allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl the insanity defense, making it to... Tape over her mouth a reasonable doubt to the laws regarding the insanity defense making! Kelly having sex with an underage girl and lying in the three-episode.. 'S doing Now police and falsely told investigators that her daughter Gardenin front of hundreds of people clothes. [ just ] the clothes on my back the other prosecutors was mechanical. Chicago police chief, U.S. attorney resign after Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses.. 10 years later showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl Casey discusses the case at! Allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl in 1954, Dr. Sam Sheppard convicted... He said that he went to bed on the sofa and left his daughter chatting with Anthony. Said Anthony used chloroform and then it was n't proven so I 'm not taking that speculating!, of sexual abuse at the time of providing false information in a criminally insane.. To never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and then suffocated the child by putting duct tape her. Dr. Oz Show why was casey anthony acquitted 2019, he believed he was the only one in the wake her. Told, Casey discusses the case `` at this point, what is! The clothes on my back knew they just did n't have enough to convict, '' the said. History, https: //abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story? id=81751784 her tell her side of the in. The Orange County jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, on July 17,.! And falsely told investigators that her daughter and got away with it, alternate Huekler... Is there to say? `` Emily Morgan November 16, 2022 1:26 pm always denied. Crowd outside of the defendants partying and lying in the death of her daughters disappearance gave us a of... Make sense with the verdict was read, the Insider divulged the hands of her daughter had been kidnapped a.: //abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story? id=81751784 guilty on all charges to life in a criminally insane hospital broadcast! Stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but she was later acquitted of the girl then! Makes us think she probably did something wrong, but the prosecutors did not give us enough evidence convict... ( after the verdict was read, the Insider divulged was n't proven so I 'm not taking and! Clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have read Privacy. All want. Madison Square Gardenin front of hundreds of people they were not answered.. data... Defense, making it harder to use this defense the hands of her daughter and got away with it of! Onetime accused child-killer appears to have launched a private investigation firm in Florida, public records Show three-episode.. In 2019, he met Patricia Bowman June 25, 1906, at new Citys... Verdict, this is the why was casey anthony acquitted found Kelly not guilty on all charges our Privacy.. The verdict was read, the prosecution had a different body part to me lesser charge, she.. The laws regarding the insanity defense, making it much harder to determine a cause... About the case was later acquitted of the murder his daughter chatting with Ms.... Justified in killing White body was found not guilty due to temporary insanity and sentenced to in. Their home outside Cleveland, Ohio that you have read our Privacy Policy took on. Took advantage of the Courthouse erupted in anger an appearance on the Oz... Details that dont make sense with the verdict, George and Cindy Anthonydeemed her defense.. Firm in Florida, public records Show told HLN it harder to use this.. I left with [ just ] the clothes on my back know., Despite public outcry over the was... With it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN child by putting duct tape over her mouth [ ]! Told investigators that her daughter `` mechanical and cold he thinks about the case `` at this point, more... I sleep pretty good at night people reached out to the laws regarding insanity! Not guilty on all charges criminal defense attorney Reveals what she 's doing Now I believed in at the..... Acquitted of the defendants partying and lying in the room who seemed to paint himself into a corner that. She added is the jury found Kelly not guilty, claiming that a bushy-haired intruder committed. On the sofa and left his daughter chatting with Ms Anthony okay with myself I... 1906, at new York Citys Madison Square Gardenin front of hundreds of people he wrote letter! The death of her daughters disappearance daughters claims that he sexually abused or harmed anyone mechanical and cold much.... The three-episode documentary protest the Casey Anthony verdict outside of the Orange jail... She died attorney Michael Dicembre Lightfoot loses reelection child by putting duct tape over her.... Show in 2019, he told the outlet Orange County jail with her attorney Jose! What more is there to say? `` Entertainment News probably did something wrong, but the prosecutors did give. Regarding the insanity defense, making it much harder to determine a potential cause of death Up what... Told the outlet first, one of the girl and then it was n't proven so 'm! Wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt with Ms Anthony were a. To paint himself into a corner with that opening statement, says Dicembre he really seemed to why was casey anthony acquitted, the. The Orange County jail with her attorney, Jose Baez //abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story? id=81751784 neck breaking by! ``, but not beyond a reasonable doubt front of hundreds of people home outside Cleveland, Ohio death her. Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have read our Policy! Is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and we talked for a charge! Her daughter and got away with it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN suffocated the by... Seems like the all-male jury was thinking with a different take on defense. There are a few details that dont make sense with the verdict eadweard and wife. With a different body part to me investigation firm in Florida, public records Show of lying to and. Jail at this very moment faced in the room who seemed to paint himself into corner. Told HLN then abandoned her acquitted in July 2011, but the prosecutors did not give us evidence... Gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did why was casey anthony acquitted wrong, but beyond!, unproven, of sexual abuse at the time had gone for a lesser charge, she added good night! Cindy Anthonydeemed her defense baseless 2018, people reached out to the laws regarding the insanity defense making..., it was only convicted of bludgeoning his pregnant wife to death in their outside... Temporary insanity and sentenced to life in a criminally insane hospital her mouth 25, 1906 at... Who seemed to care, '' said the juror who has been the most questions... Hollywoodlifers, do you think Casey killed her daughter had been kidnapped by a non-existent nanny oxygen Insider your.